At the request of one of the readers here at VirtuaGirlReview, I reviewed Shabba, whom he said was as acrobatic as Suzie Q, but with more dancing ability.  After my review of her, he asked me which I thought was better and gave me his own comparison.  I’ve decided to do a apples-to-apples, side-by-side comparison of the two desktop dancers here, using their respective best-rated cards (on VirtuaGirlHD).  The two cards chosen here are their top-rated cards as of this writing.

So, this comparison is:

Shabba – Fitness Lesson	vs.	Suzie Q – No Gravity
(link to VGR review)		(link to VGR review)
Pole Dancing
She is a good pole dancer, lithe and flexible and good at the basic gymnastics that make for entertaining “wows” when on the pole. Her moves are basic, but even those are beyond what most professional dancers/strippers/pole dancers are capable of.  This makes her unusual. Score: 8		She is beyond acrobatic on the pole and is limited only by the amount of space and time she has to perform with.  She both “wows” and makes her performance look easy. Her moves are advanced and have won her awards in the professional pole dancing circuit. Score: 10
Physical Looks
This, of course, is subjective, but while Shabba is beautiful, she is not the style of beauty that I prefer and appears a little “flat” in facial features.  Her expression and great, but not perfectly toned, body make up for this, though. Score: 10		Some do not like Suzie Q because of her gymnast’s build and musculature.  Personally, I like this as well as her ruddy redhead look.  Even without her extreme pole skills, I’d consider her a top VirtuaGirl just for her classic look alone. Score: 10
Desktop Dancing
Shabba isn’t the best performer to ever appear on VirtuaGirlHD, but she is a very good one.  Her desktop dancer skills are good, her movements smooth, and she is a joy to watch. Score: 10		Probably her major weak point, Suzie Q is not what anyone would call a smooth or great dancer.  Her moves are mainly meant for the crowded room stage, where flair is more important than flow. Score: 7
Attitude
As mentioned before, Shabba’s attitude and fun demeanor are a big part of her physical beauty.  She gives the impression that she is not doing her job on stage, but is instead having a good time and wants you to be a part of it. This detracts from the sensuality some, but is better than the robotic attitude of some other VirtuaGirls. Score: 9		Suzie Q is a professional and has a classy attitude and demeanor.  She has a great smile and isn’t afraid to show it, however, and she occasionally gives a chuckle or goofy expression that shows she’s not a stiff stage queen.  Overall, she has a good attitude that fits her style well and makes for a great performance. Score: 10
Totals
Shabba: 9.25		9.25 :Suzie Q

To be honest, I’d expected Suzie Q to edge out Shabba when the totals came in, but was surprised to see a perfect tie.  Before doing this analysis, had you asked me which girl was better, I would have immediately said it was Suzie.  Now?  Well, I guess I’ll have to finish out my Shabba collection.